{
"schemaVersion": "beauty-direct-inspection-ledger-v1",
"reviewedAt": "2026-07-27T22:14:42.9899967Z",
"generatedAt": "2026-07-27T22:14:49.846Z",
"reviewer": "Direct Codex inspection of the four fresh post-renderer-migration Chrome screenshots; not a human-participant study and not a Responses API visual-critic run.",
"evidencePolicy": {
"directVisualBasis": "The current migrated final page passed a separate direct review of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots. The prior six-view shortlist review is retained only as selection provenance.",
"finalCaptureBasis": "Fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome captures and runtime metrics are bound to the exact post-migration HTML and committed renderer-style migration report.",
"nonClaims": [
"No human-participant study was performed.",
"No Responses API visual-critic run is represented by this ledger.",
"The pre-migration direct review is not represented as visual approval of changed renderer CSS."
]
},
"integrityBinding": {
"planPath": "reports/direct-inspection-plan.json",
"planSha256": "4ba383df674ab332d369e3e8e6dbca5b7b5c9ee9f4871788ca729e4e45f75266",
"acceptedInventoryPath": "reports/post-review-accepted-inventory.json",
"acceptedInventorySha256": "cb422955be167bdd14bb37cb2d77b275b949f8d45f564986997101ede79c946e",
"materializationReportPath": "reports/post-review-materialization.json",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"screenshotInventoryPath": "browser-qa/screenshot-inventory.json",
"screenshotInventorySha256": "8f52a7c01111553fbd7639e53ef2c62292533f7595ee94086863fedf59bb24da",
"browserMetricsPath": "browser-qa/browser-metrics.json",
"browserMetricsSha256": "dc1a8dcd56b95844e518dd5e2be8791f0177ad64513ed92e9ecae3262a3fe7ae",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportPath": "reports/renderer-style-migration-v1.json",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"postMigrationReviewPath": "browser-qa/post-migration-direct-inspection-decisions.json",
"postMigrationReviewSha256": "25b87bc54303fc8d4ff0256d0580d58cbf687147fca4344e265f790c6e30edb9"
},
"summary": {
"planned": 52,
"entries": 52,
"passed": 52,
"failed": 0,
"needsReview": 0,
"requiredViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checksPerEntry": [
"firstViewportClarity",
"bookingVisibility",
"typographyAndWrapping",
"imageCropAndFallback",
"responsiveComposition",
"noOverflowOrOverlap"
],
"directStaticViewsPerSelectedCandidate": 4,
"freshCaptureViewportsPerEntry": 4,
"evidenceMode": "POST_RENDERER_STYLE_MIGRATION",
"blockers": []
},
"entries": [
{
"pageId": "atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 1,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich",
"nearest-duplication-ceiling"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 95,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "1c7f114bab1d2f206b1a7f1c7fec428f66655b0a06930503bb722f22f5d0d65a",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "e9e235f7c587ac3877147bda1e0049003eaf31f75334412332e7f99c44036ce6",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 1 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 8,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 95,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "eaa13f33a506a48d500d66fae1f00ab2de67da0df00354d6f1609b4dc2cc786e",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "3ef0872687189fafe22cfa709a8d504451f3e78f8a6be496b2a31e613c0d76f5",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 8 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-split-portrait--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 2,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 95,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "ca2af6e78f4be811db3546c657a67992598b4597dd465fd9991105324f749563",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "853a63982230c0c1c8883d2e49e4bf7d179c8a27d1d402cca327d0e8f14168b1",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 2 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-split-portrait--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-type-canvas--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 17,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "0f9665b78711131e1d454b5ed2ef3a29f1c9dd3c1ef8fdb42f3f6ccc0d0f7a3e",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "929fa7599316ff3af17e43b03ca786a8264f05e1fc3c5b5978a0732bacafc233",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 17 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-type-canvas--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-axis--rich-3",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 1,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich",
"nearest-capsule-adherence-floor"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "37ba3fc4b0378f8630e17553c3a7b5070766f58e63771b8b48a38cf23cac3aa6",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "fc59f3066fd5269b685620d2bd2dd0bbe2256b0ff187cd00724e17e2bf6fd71b",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 1 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-axis--rich-3 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-dark-frame--rich-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 17,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "db4e45ac1523893fbf737daf0387f81da8f3460760d80b0563a82b05a33e2b2c",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "306c6833017895f6e810798d986c5f5d5e1627fa03256bb4ed8f2c8b19772185",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 17 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-dark-frame--rich-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-toolline--rich-3",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 14,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "c8bdeec3236805b682a7f6a485f0253087c4357b1621bfe74b5724a7c05d4d8b",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "9077de556b0ac8f12a5dacbf8d0398e6d018b23ed7c02465b27ce3f74af366ac",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 14 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-toolline--rich-3 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-typographic-cut--rich-2",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-2--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 18,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "0c82f509836d159135fc08382dc8516ba83815b48f30ba51e23fb9b1698991a8",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "12b59cee734e4e43e8ee20c64a78623467efc822a5ba4746aad63185ca02c7db",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 18 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-typographic-cut--rich-2 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-2--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 2,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 97,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "abf4469a39d8c78e138f7bcb8c92895556a289d9bbfc064f7085de52b02dedd6",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "c6404a80b6fc863c199576560f050abf6f21ddc8e721185876efa277eda4f3e6",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 2 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 5,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "c109e2dddccf20fe2cdedcaca82d10d23103e16effa5685bff41640adb791164",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "890e2eb7115f35d04214a9b80a15b91f12b8b00099a6a66faa60a3998adaf3bc",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 5 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-quiet-column--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 5,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "0b06d199410e3a1338c5cc092f760a6f3c00f09990ff0bf086639741ff3d684e",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "d7dd30918383c379e1323c6920de4ce86a24f7c6b29e4d475e4c90d6aead91cb",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 5 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-quiet-column--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 3,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 97,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "88390fb7c4a0302566f2d4b7d12a8fc55e465ca0ab690eee1e7444cb50938399",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "fd77165c1c889b89292c395cfbbaf53625bb8cef62944054e911ddefeb654d86",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 3 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-gallery-index--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 7,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "80d7253aa80921734d2b3a980ec57cc0bd79143655079c2ec5a6fc525fe020a2",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "65d56dbb22359c5bc02628b35804d5334cd389037163bac4370b425855eaa755",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 7 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-gallery-index--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 23,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "549e6249f24fd763aa3015f0bea334793df318ba28204f7b56128033d92f37bc",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "a6514526c59d965fca90a824cd5cc1427ec7a8279a82a09db670ce57f725ece1",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 23 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 6,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "a0cbaba18805071b543bddd45759a4826e76bbfd746665eee15d9e1ada2dcf33",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "ecf7a4e06499b88a85f3fb15b19274640dc0fc4730d79507e81ec84e5a1f5646",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 6 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-offset-pop--rich-3",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 18,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-rich"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "0a3ee45a56872cd158e47398d6bb09c0fa39d9eb7119541a158eb8c9660e7b0b",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "4619452ed0d96ebb150f68d9b3ab9a0ad61584cfbf29bf94eb6b8afcb452031b",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 18 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-offset-pop--rich-3 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 3,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse",
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "76a1ae1329cc3daaaf04795f0e4f54d1a3eb7b6a80674d630a3c07216f05fb31",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "07a3621ee9e486517c59cc33f218ad496d288d1e2a8cc7e39df1f26abc2566b5",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 3 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 9,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "a6df7ce552312ac16145d2d1966d11aff74ec6fd170aa9e36d759f85f0089811",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "1230df7cc0d368cbde4417ce4d96bcd713c195a627bfd367ff62260ad6e285ef",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 9 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-gallery-spread--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 10,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "3057e3ff03fc04308c0cc0b3c256c916e529bce712af7cb308705cba191e4278",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "042d0353136c48ccbb33cc03b4064d7fa3c1546f028dbaf59ca93cebd870a05e",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 10 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-split-portrait--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 9,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 95,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "a626b86ca8148fcfcfecaf0d2ef042c06ed11ad9c5eb2efe02ca8d496ec3d7db",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "122ecfb34318ee43d77a8d7d55b9201bfc6add49161a1ba8b6346f2f0442d851",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 9 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-type-canvas--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-axis--sparse-2",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-2--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 17,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "d7e94ff40fa02d2644002acb52dc8cc5913203a0160cfadf1c6bb6985c99e0e0",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "c283dd9823fd1fc0354aed75ce01279bdbba336219429e671ddd305d70f859f7",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 17 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-axis--sparse-2 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-2--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-dark-frame--sparse-3",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-3--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 14,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "77e890d2a4d8125a62273c2ca30b5b0f372208894f735d4e7dcce7c8540a24da",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "b460c216a77222d0dade5fcbf0eba126de53b3a868d958a8dfd8e7f724290159",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 14 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-dark-frame--sparse-3 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-3--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-toolline--sparse-2",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-2--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 15,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "a7a22c06be84d271bfeefd71f335ccd509f50a22ee40e31128691b40616e3f15",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "a40a9737532446db590701a689b21aa8ff5e96ae8ff5c7ef617a2146401e6ce4",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 15 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-toolline--sparse-2 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-2--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 7,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "ec56c99ba8dda9de101a7575b58ce3352d976b8575e8ea5f7639cbeeb7fe594f",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "412a32e893596d227a5b0bea1bd8477961fe0050aaefae3095850beb3c306de4",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 7 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 0,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "2c2c56637b4c02fbd4d4a6c02cfc1409c3d83fb745880d10ddf04ecc02faf0d9",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "993e40ed80db027c81adf387487c145bc638f96dc1e977241d6ac8fe89372333",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 0 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 10,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "ae55ae58b315222cbe70b386bb7f9e3ba852a4b1dd67e5ea73499c160572f88f",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "f759ab3f35c0fa6b08d4fa435fe7953702a1a1d36ccf3874a2836b877dbc1bdf",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 10 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-full-bleed-pause--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 8,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "1b305319fd66899dfc02be2319c6992ccb261c52c8526f6f34b401e41e7b537d",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "3e4a7653b6f692e3d2ac656dd33ce96981134dc7f2a6f1faeb976d3e63b0c418",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 8 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 3,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 97,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "059745779005c993e36ad171e53a34aec75635f1bf7e7045fdc070c737858a65",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "5f2c27d5fc3dc9ce19656ee16357ba9eaf3d8c22ed6718a959359a83c4b07290",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 3 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-soft-diptych--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-gallery-index--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 9,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "b9c872ae0b562713eb39e3e780eed08f921c91f13f542ffe62f8cf7baa7f414d",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "459ae232e99a70ba37431d96c69b1e30e8a6f0f666efcd855e6d30dc0e7a3e45",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 9 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-gallery-index--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 5,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "82356827713aa5009b5c980394e0fa065f4055cf641b56996a1879f6b8d71496",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "7725eba7597b1cd347b88b2ed5dbdb6ef96e0cbae516609c6216245d5bf0d4af",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 5 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 11,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "2a01764b7766c2dd6fa3a9b6ea964c999df6aafefd5bacfb86cbfb421f1d1f8d",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "f4ad856d340f15958542be18f43864bfafb6d74d800d514c6822b0d44c36e9ef",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 11 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-monochrome-punch--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-offset-pop--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 6,
"selectionReasons": [
"gold-master-sparse"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "64a7d0bd9963872b4643ff0bd2ff6fd12894339a3736a275e204318e9431b210",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "2c02178ecf515f100a49bf8bd03c591a5e08f2dfa038f7b21fbde5ce97ed9a92",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 6 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-offset-pop--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-axis--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 11,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent",
"nearest-capsule-adherence-floor"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "1570eab6507ee988cb9a5ca8c9f9fcba411bf987b423b6f5695d9976430191fa",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "361816cc69ba7aa8a4534cc9fe4ca80511800cf4ccf0865073fe4e5f00f09c24",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 11 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-axis--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-axis--sparse-3",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-3--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 2,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "e76b5d3391a01895f25865089cce0a6f912494e7e512b4656598c7ee62492644",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "2301aa55b91bf18f5fc62c8feb7f5c5a9640e4061f0d83080cb042c83a3041e3",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 2 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-axis--sparse-3 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--sparse-3--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-dark-frame--sparse-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 17,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "030d23dcadc677dfa623de779bc96439c7dac93ee62c1ff0d975910fbd5b2766",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "83329dbf54bf0de069578264f5fb08c8237d119a1eda149e012256bc5f26965f",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 17 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-dark-frame--sparse-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-toolline--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 19,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "7d3f15d962591f99d493b0cc72b3b720d154649d3c84297d7ab5592609df9ca1",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "e0595213af5aa13c91f3c1dcc25531211f22f50450bfa0682acd53d64682f40a",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 19 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-toolline--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-toolline--sparse-3",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-3--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 16,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "64732862a5a75d35ba15b0eed1db0bd29a87defac02ce886520bfae1cd2488e5",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "949883dcecc82127156d2a3a8aeb65df317f749e572edee5d9b8d05c85185885",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 16 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-toolline--sparse-3 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--sparse-3--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-typographic-cut--rich-3",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 11,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "643b6739ff6bbc09dd206639c433fc08c89facc116f93a3783806eec81d29e7d",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "27514f15419ab083bb3f34fd64d5239e1ff31284383782b2aa9c7b3844fd0578",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 11 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-typographic-cut--rich-3 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-axis--rich-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 2,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "f1f5afe749b34a05a7b7d659601841ab4fd526339dd9c058003c98cd394df2bd",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "cd336ba7df8e9e634dc2d9642dd38dbe04cc554bd9d7fce27546a23d5f2ffca1",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 2 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-axis--rich-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-axis--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-dark-frame--rich-2",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-2--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 1,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "71386cdd0336811a0927bebb2956f9a68f76be75325e6b4740ee039da01e4068",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "f280739c892f424064a167204d86193a506cd56114ca3780676822631e70bcb7",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 1 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-dark-frame--rich-2 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-2--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-dark-frame--sparse-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 6,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "aa1e2ef95138ebed7b82946b8509c1dce2fea75cda134033dbadd9885ff7850c",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "7a081d075aa347ef5a370c12024d6d6142c5e3291aec4fe9fec8450e063fe433",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 6 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-dark-frame--sparse-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-toolline--rich-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 2,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "346c3598b38020d38f3f45816f04633d43f13c28f44a5556b1165e3cb74324d0",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "54d8aebc875e934ffc06454bc9fb3391a58e79e43b6cab6acfdf9df3613ef5b0",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 2 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-toolline--rich-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-toolline--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 11,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 96,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "3d5d46da8bb3306f7faf64e8114be796f27cb9e9d491e917bd8003ac5402d884",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "2e948378b585ae53f689dfaf147762ea4a1dd977a99b0597e493fd4d2de703a1",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 11 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-typographic-cut--sparse-2--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 10,
"selectionReasons": [
"bottom-ten-percent"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 94,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "cdab19140bd98eb9139f4c08677f7caee74b7ea34c43e0076149e506e315d7ba",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "15dd8afac0236c5890afe2fbf0e1ad7aae54840ed47e4607fb01a0820725a71e",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 10 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--sparse-2--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 16,
"selectionReasons": [
"nearest-duplication-ceiling"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 95,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "4ced3ea87047e725ffdf87c3d41398a80a75949514072338695c057627595920",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "667b31f998156de55d1a147401ce103593b4af84cd5d053c47c9f822303253f5",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 16 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/atelier-framed-panorama--rich-2--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 11,
"selectionReasons": [
"deterministic-random-audit"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 97,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "92989f879eba24993dfa2d5cde416959fb1e8ccb8dd0fe623dbf4f7ae0cabca7",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "8398643a2a6cec7b1faebe61e6861293a8b8dc0ce7e0724beea307f2d3e81877",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 11 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-asymmetric-mineral--rich-3--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-offset-pop--sparse-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 1,
"selectionReasons": [
"deterministic-random-audit"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "43e625ee7d53b15312d4fe980d4a59ca027f0d6d6ceddc86c676b4e6627c07b5",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "2448d0fcd3db87ad4d40c9977894659aa95e33d6d550140a8be76ba0b2757f1c",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 1 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-offset-pop--sparse-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 6,
"selectionReasons": [
"deterministic-random-audit"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "acf453656290c44ec639f031b47657efdf7e07056d76e0184ef44417b5aba89c",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "a0708359e548e7d8b5b54817846934d7b025dac9788429c484bf8ea745a3216c",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 6 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/ritual-quiet-column--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-offset-pop--rich-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 5,
"selectionReasons": [
"deterministic-random-audit"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "e0b93433263b443da5d98790f118d9ea13f8556b4e4f6281c004892700bcd590",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "3b062bd69d914c8ce7730160649bfa797f3155c25bb2a1ef644e30deed54b566",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 5 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-offset-pop--rich-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-offset-pop--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "precision-dark-frame--rich-1",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 7,
"selectionReasons": [
"deterministic-random-audit"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 98
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "41ae2a73adafb9b957dc3f8d13a81275470b066b002c802e143cd8e311055ebf",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "57e0d40baf11685282390ce9a545c86fce8325223dc337ba35b2a6d98111a599",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 7 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. precision-dark-frame--rich-1 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-1--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-1--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-1--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/precision-dark-frame--rich-1--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-gallery-index--sparse-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 11,
"selectionReasons": [
"deterministic-random-audit"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 95,
"coherence": 97,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "8694a86f5a7dafe669453700c59dc0d5f9a746456b09d0c560d6c2cf7c1f1208",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "d6385904dae79ae0bfc0bb6ecf043995e6e34e1091d7f571fe29daa68c54acf2",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 11 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-gallery-index--sparse-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-gallery-index--sparse-4--1920x1080.png"
]
},
{
"pageId": "studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4",
"status": "pass",
"inspectedViewports": [
"mobile",
"tablet",
"desktop",
"wide"
],
"checks": {
"firstViewportClarity": true,
"bookingVisibility": true,
"typographyAndWrapping": true,
"imageCropAndFallback": true,
"responsiveComposition": true,
"noOverflowOrOverlap": true
},
"notes": "The migrated final page passed direct Codex inspection of its fresh mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide Chrome screenshots. Screenshots and runtime metrics are bound to the renderer-style migration report and exact post-migration HTML. This is not a human-participant study or a Responses API critique.",
"screenshotRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
],
"evidenceClassification": {
"visualInspectionBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_DIRECT_CODEX_FOUR_VIEW_SCREENSHOT_REVIEW",
"freshCaptureBasis": "POST_RENDERER_MIGRATION_HASH_BOUND_CHROME_CAPTURE",
"humanParticipantStudy": false,
"responsesApiVisualCritic": false
},
"selectedOrdinal": 17,
"selectionReasons": [
"deterministic-random-audit"
],
"qualityScores": {
"overall": 96,
"coherence": 98,
"capsuleAdherence": 99
},
"integrityBinding": {
"acceptedHtmlSha256": "dd022ca6e2d7c9fffedc9c8068bd4690d3c6ff7d79e253d5f4e32e73a42c7c55",
"preMigrationAcceptedHtmlSha256": "86351cb3461091c2f3cf863b4605b372153102309152912553fd1c3623c1aa34",
"materializationReportSha256": "005cd6d92f38dae075b9e4ea3de1840d5845a59823bc71e65d33e6d6391bff00",
"rendererStyleMigrationReportSha256": "a62783d6339ced52762fbeab0ba79017aa73e43a7c120ca3442f7f7fa2c8ec8e",
"finalHtmlHashValid": true,
"selectedShortlistHtmlHashValid": true,
"screenshotHashCount": 4,
"screenshotHashesValid": true,
"runtimeMeasurementCount": 4
},
"checkEvidence": {
"firstViewportClarity": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"selected candidate 17 post-renderer-migration direct screenshot decision",
"4 fresh renderer-migration-bound Chrome captures",
"4 renderer-migration-bound browser metric records",
"primary action visible in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"bookingVisibility": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected hidden or competing primary actions",
"fresh primary action target is visible and at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"typographyAndWrapping": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected material title-wrap, clipping, or collision defects",
"intended body and display faces loaded in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"imageCropAndFallback": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review rejected material crop and fallback defects in all four current screenshots",
"fresh browser metrics contain no failed image/resource request"
],
"blockers": []
},
"responsiveComposition": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"post-migration direct review inspected the current mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots",
"fresh captures and metrics cover mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide viewports",
"reduced-motion policy verified in every fresh viewport"
],
"blockers": []
},
"noOverflowOrOverlap": {
"passed": true,
"evidence": [
"direct review rejected visible clipping, collision, and overflow",
"fresh horizontal overflow measurement is zero in every viewport"
],
"blockers": []
}
},
"directReviewSummary": "Directly inspected the post-migration mobile, tablet, desktop, and wide screenshots in the contact-sheet review set. studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4 retained clear business/category/locality hierarchy, an immediately discoverable primary action, intentional type wrapping, coherent media or procedural fallback, viewport-specific composition, and no visible overflow, overlap, clipping, or cross-capsule style drift.",
"directReviewEvidenceRefs": [
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4--390x844.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4--768x1024.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4--1440x1000.png",
"browser-qa/screenshots/studio-lacquer-grid--rich-4--1920x1080.png"
]
}
]
}